Discussions Using Del.icio.us

After having posted my Super-Fast Delicious Bookmarklet yesterday, it became quite a hit on del.icio.us. As I watched the links come in I noticed one recurring trend: A lot of users were tagging their links with the cryptic ‘%s‘. I thought for a minute and realized that these users were adding the bookmarklet to their toolbar – then clicking it (which is not the right thing to do).

Anyway, why I was digging through these links I came across one user who had posed a question in his extended description:

I don’t quite get this but sense it could be good – question: can the config change be adapted jus to close tab + not window?

There was an easy answer to this – so I visited his del.icio.us page looking for a way to contact him (email, web site, etc.) – but one did not exist. So this posed a quandry: How does one respond to a question on del.icio.us?

The only way that you can ‘contact’ someone in del.icio.us is to tag a link using the for: prepend – and that’s exactly what I did.

But this brings up a couple questions:

  • What should the URL for the site be?
  • If your contact is browsing through lots of links – and you want him to see yours, what can you do to attract his eye to it?
  • How do you make it apparent, to users who read your links but aren’t that person, what it is that you’re replying to?

I feel as if I was able to tackle the first two problems fairly well, but the last one posed some definite issues.

I solved the first problem by using the original URL for the link, but tacking a #for:peacay at the end. This makes the URL unique – but still provides some context for the discussion.

I solved the second problem by making use of HTML character entities, specifically the arrows. Delicious does not allow you to embed entities directly, but it does support unicode – so I simply copied the visual representation of the arrows that I wanted, pasted them into the ‘description’ field, and was well on my way. You can see the final result here:

The final problem is the hardest one – and I’m still not sure how to solve it. The idea of having permanent links to a bookmark on delicious has been discussed many times before. If a permanent link existed for this guy’s bookmark, I could tag that URL directly – creating a sort of pseudo-threading and giving context to everyone reading it.

Being able to create a usable threading/discussion situation for del.icio.us would definitely be cool – but I’m just not sure that we’re entirely there yet.

Posted: August 8th, 2005


Subscribe for email updates

1 Comment (Show Comments)



Comments are closed.
Comments are automatically turned off two weeks after the original post. If you have a question concerning the content of this post, please feel free to contact me.


Secrets of the JavaScript Ninja

Secrets of the JS Ninja

Secret techniques of top JavaScript programmers. Published by Manning.

John Resig Twitter Updates

@jeresig

Infrequent, short, updates and links.